Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows – Part 1

November 17, 2010 — 2 Comments

It’s begun. The beginning of the end. After the 7th book came out, and left me unsatisfied — a feeling carried over the 6th book and the 5th film — I swore to never see Harry Potter at the cinema ever again. A promise easy to keep with the 6th film, but then… it was hard to keep it when the first promotional materials for HP7 were released.

Well played, Warner. Well played.

Deathly Hallows is perhaps Yates’ best attempt at a Harry Potter adaption, but considering the other two – it isn’t saying that much. In the greater scale of things, it might follow on Azkaban’s footsteps as an interesting film filled with anguish and desperation… of I guess, the teenage sort. If the book didn’t work for you, the film seems to improve on action and characters. It’s also of great comfort to say that The WB’s decision of splitting the film in two parts was hardly a bad commercial or creative choice… at least for the fans of the books, who will savor each an every detail.

But then again, considering how many chapters were crammed into this first part, one has to wonder what’s left for part two if not only the “last battle” which, in the book, happened off-page… and that epilogue that’s ripped out of the most poorly written fanfiction.

For the non-readers or those who haven’t seen HP6… well, you’re screwed. It really doesn’t work without the background, and you’re better without watching it, if you’re going to start complaining. Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows feels like made for the fans of the series only.

The film picks up right after the events on HP6, as Voldemort’s plans have been discovered by the general public,  his group of Death Eaters must act quickly. Taking over the Ministry of Magic, and creating chaos in and out of the Magical world, killing Muggles and making headlines in “our” world.

Harry’s family is ditched quickly from the story, and Harry’s left alone as he waits for the Order of the Phoenix to pick him up on the day of his 17th birthday — Harry’s finally of legal Wizardry age. He can perform magic now without being tracked, which will prove to be helpful for his non-school activities with Hermione and Ron in their search for Horcruxes — in simple terms, Volvemort’s soul-pieces.

The situation is grim, but Kloves (back again for a Potter adaptation) never forgets the wedding, and there’s humor between those dark moments. It’s needed for the younger crowd, otherwise they wouldn’t be able to take it. The staying in the woods, all alone, no human contact except for the three of them. To top it all off, they’ve got a task, but they don’t know how to get there.

Deathly Hallows Part 1 lays heavily on Daniel Radcliffe, Emma Watson and Rupert Grint, and it’s comforting to see them all grown and as more “seasoned” actors. They have learned their craft from the creme de la creme of British actors, and it’s good. The chemistry between them, friends as long as the characters have been, shows on their scenes… we could just wish it could be a Rated R edited version. The devastation would have been that much more powerful. There’s that thing about not showing blood in children’s films, there’s a little bit of blood in Harry Potter — two scenes jump out — but those “blood scenes” could have been saved for a particular scene with Hermione, someone we are much more invested on.

Yates’ Deathly Hallows is more than an apt adaptation of the book, it captures the spirit of it an enhances it for the screen in a way that Cuaron’s captured the spirit of Azkaban. Not quite there yet because Azkaban is a better developed book, but up there among Potter movie adaptations.

Still… I feel Part 2 is going to be dreadful.


2 responses to Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows – Part 1

  1. Your score is quite high for such a harsh text.

  2. I really enjoyed it. I mean, for a book I really didn’t felt like it did justice to the first books… I really enjoyed the film. The film is technically fine, and it’s got some very nice performances — that bit with Daniel Radcliffe doing a little bit of all the other characters was quite funny and genius. That alone gives this a passing of 3/5

    The extra half a star is for actually improving the characterization of Ron. He’s pretty much 1/3 of the story. However, in the book it comes off a lot more like pure whining. It was “Ron My-Mom-Cooks-Freshly-Meals-Everyday” “Ron My-Mom-Does-My-Laundry” and Hermione spent half the day crying… in part because it was such a depressing situation… and in part because Ron was being such a baby.

    So kudos to the film to actually fix that.

    Having said that, they were able to put the 900 pages of Book5 into the shortest film of the series, if they could pull that off, they could have fit the chapters that are left into this one. Really, Joel — I heard people complaining that HP6 was too gimmicky because it was flashbacks. The rest of HP7 is going to be backstory and the final battle. xD

    As for it not being non-fan-friendly… it’s a series that chronicles the life of a wizard. We can’t expect the filmmakers telling us what we’re missing if we haven’t even bothered to watch the films to fill us in every time. It’s like reading Narnia Book 7, and expect to learn what is Narnia xD

Leave a Reply